We decided to add a rating system when we are trying out new recipes. I’ll ask each of the members of my family to rate the dishes based on the following rating system (copied from Netflix).
Loved it!
Really liked it!
Liked it!
Didn’t like it!
Hated it!
We’ll specify who gave what rating;  Dad, Me, K (age 7), and E (age 5). Hopefully this will help you decide on whether you would like to try out something new as well.